This is a little old (three weeks or so), but John Dominic Crossan on The Passion:
Here is the hard question: What have you, Mr. Gibson, as a conscientious Christian who knows very well that the passion story has repeatedly grounded lethal anti-Jewish prejudice, done to cauterize that potential venom in making this film? My answer: Nothing, actually. He has, in my judgment, shown careless irresponsibility, culpable negligence, and even depraved indifference to the dangers of anti-Semitism here and abroad. If you juggle with dynamite you are accountable for collateral damage.
Yeah, that’s it. Is Mel Gibson anti-Semitic? I don’t know. Alex doesn’t know. Probably Mel doesn’t know. There’s some evidence either way. But the effect of his Jesus movie is most certainly anti-Semitic, and he knew, or should have known, that it would be perceived that way, and rather than doing something about it embraced the controversy as a marketing tool.
